Questions on Quran
Dear Muslim readers, in the name of Isa al-Masih [Jesus Christ], As-salamu alaykum!
May God [Hebrew: Elohim(אֱלהִים); Arabic: Allah(الله)] bless you!
The questions in this section may come as a surprise or even a shock to you. It is quite possible that many of the questions posed here are ones you have never encountered before. If you have any objections regarding these questions, or if you require further clarification, please do write to us.
We have no intention of disparaging Muslims or the Islamic faith. Should anything be perceived as such, please understand that it is entirely unintentional—a mere oversight. If any such instances occur, please bring them to our attention, and we will correct them.
The truth can often be harsh, difficult, or bitter; for this, we offer no apology. However, if there are any shortcomings in the manner in which the truth is presented, we apologize in advance.
Our sole objective is to present the truth in detail and to uncover it through incisive, probing questions. The articles and questions on this website have been crafted with this purpose in mind. It should be noted that just as Muslims have the right to profess their faith, others [non-Muslims] also possess the right to question that faith. Please note that this is not a criticism, but an inquiry. We are asking for details regarding the faith you profess. If you have answers, please share them. If you do not, consult your religious leaders or scholars. If you still cannot find satisfactory answers, engage in self-reflection; abandon falsehood and seek the truth.
The questions below are primarily directed at those who propagate the Islamic faith. Nevertheless, we extend a cordial invitation to all sincere Muslims to provide accurate and detailed responses to these questions concerning your beliefs.
May Allah have mercy on you all and guide you to the absolute truth!
Question # 1
The son involved in the sacrifice of Abraham
If you maintain that it was Ishmael (Ismail)—and not Isaac (Ishaq)—whom Abraham intended to sacrifice in obedience to God’s command, then why does the Quran, in its account of this event (Surah 37:99–113), mention only Isaac (Ishaq) by name, while failing to mention Ishmael (Ismail) at all?
Question # 2
The son who was not present during the sacrifice by Abraham
When describing the occasion where Abraham intended to offer his son as a sacrifice, the Quran explicitly mentions Isaac (Ishaq). Why, then, do you mislead innocent people by claiming that the son Abraham intended to sacrifice was Ishmael (Ismail)—a name that is not even mentioned in the Quran in the context of this event (Surah 37:113)?
Question # 3
Descendants included in the lineage of prophets
The Quran provides clear testimony that God included the sons/descendants of Isaac (Ishaq) in the lineage of prophets (Surah 45:16). It is through this truth that the true line of prophets continued from the lineage of Isaac. This is why Jesus (Isa)—the Al-Masih (Christ) promised by God—came into this world from that very lineage. Both the Bible and the Quran proclaim his greatness.
However, neither the Bible nor the Quran states that the sons/descendants of Ishmael (Ismail) were granted a place within the lineage of prophets. How, then, can Muhammad—who emerged from among them—be a prophet? How could he be a great prophet? And how could he be included in the lineage of true prophets?
Question # 4
The Good News of the Son
The Quran bears witness to the teaching found in the Torah—that among the sons of Abraham, Isaac (Ishaq) holds a greater and more distinct status than Ishmael (Ismail).
The Quran explicitly confirms that God conveyed the good news of Isaac’s (Ishaq’s) birth to both his mother and his father in advance (Surah 11:71 & 37:112).
Ishmael (Ismail) does not possess this same distinction or greatness. On what basis, then, is it suggested that Ishmael (Ismail) is greater than Isaac (Ishaq)?
Question # 5
The Offering of the Great Sacrificial Animal
The Quran states that God declared regarding Abraham’s son: “We ransomed the boy with a great sacrificial animal” (Surah 37:107).
In this context within the Quran:
(a) What is this ‘great sacrificial animal’? Why was a sacrificial animal necessary here in the first place? And who offered this sacrifice, and to whom was it offered?
(b) To whom was the ‘ransom’—provided by God Himself—given? Why was it necessary for God to pay a ‘ransom’ in the first place?
(c) From whom did God ‘rescue’ Abraham’s son? Why would God—instead of simply exercising His own command, power, authority, or sovereign status to save a single boy—resort to paying a ‘ransom’ to secure his release?
Question # 6
The Name of the Creator
In the Bible [the Torah, the Psalms, and the Gospel], God—the Creator [Elohim]—has clearly revealed His personal name. The prophets not only used this name but also affirmed the truth that it is, indeed, the name of God. “Moses asked God, ‘If I go to the Israelites and say to them, “The God [Elohim] of your fathers has sent me to you,” and they ask me, “What is His name?” what shall I tell them?’ God [Elohim] replied to Moses, ‘I AM WHO I AM [YHWH].’ He added, ‘Say this to the Israelites: “I AM [YHWH] has sent me to you.”’ Furthermore, God said to Moses, ‘Tell the Israelites this: “The LORD [YHWH—‘I AM’], the God [Elohim] of your fathers—the God [Elohim] of Abraham, the God [Elohim] of Isaac, and the God [Elohim] of Jacob—has sent me to you.” This is My name forever; this is how I am to be remembered throughout all generations.’” (Exodus 3:13-15)
“I am Jehovah [יְהוָֹה/Yod-He-Vav-He = The One Who Is]; this is My name. I will not give My glory to another, nor will I allow the praise due to Me to be given to idols.” (Isaiah 42:8)
“Therefore, I will make them know—this time I will make them experience—that My name is Jehovah [יְהוָֹה/Yod-He-Vav-He = The One Who Is]; I will let them know the extent of My power and My might.” (Jeremiah 16:21)
“Jehovah [יְהוָֹה/Yod-He-Vav-He = The One Who Is]—Jehovah of Hosts is His memorial name.” (Hosea 12:5)
“His name is Jehovah [יְהוָֹה/Yod-He-Vav-He = The One Who Is]; He brings destruction upon the mighty, causing strongholds to fall into ruin.” (Amos 5:9)
In the Quran, which is in the Arabic language, the term Allah [الله = God] is used to refer to God or the Creator. This is a common noun in the Arabic language; however, it is not the personal name of the Creator. Nowhere in the Quran does the Creator declare that “Allah” [الله = God] is His personal name. However, Islamic proselytizers often teach that “Allah” [الله = God] is the personal name of the Creator. This is a teaching that is not found in the Quran!
Note: The Quran contains phrases such as “I am Allah” (meaning “I am God”). Similarly, expressions like “in the name of Allah” (meaning “in the name of God”) or “the name of Allah” (meaning “the name of God”) are also used in the Quran. However, there is no explicit statement in the Quran where God declares, “My name is Allah.”
In the Bible, the God/Creator of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob clearly revealed His personal name as Jehovah [יְהוָֹה / Yod-He-Vav-He — meaning “He Who Is”]. If, as you teach, “Allah” [الله — meaning “God”] is the personal name of the God/Creator, can you provide even one piece of evidence from the Quran where God/Creator explicitly declares, “My name is Allah”?
Question #7
Where did Isa (Jesus) say, “I am God”?
Muslim apologists often ask Christians, “Where in the Bible does Jesus himself say, ‘I am God; worship Me’?” They often pose such questions. Seekers of truth should realize that these questions are not asked out of a genuine desire to discover the truth; rather, they are ignorant questions wrapped in a deceptive guise.
In this context, those who propagate such challenges—imposing specific conditions—must first be able to answer the following questions, which are subject to those very same conditions. If they pose such a question to Christians without being able to provide an answer themselves, they effectively prove that their own question is merely an ignorant one, rooted in hypocrisy:
a) Muslims believe that Muhammad is the final prophet. Therefore, according to your own beliefs, where in the Quran does it state that Muhammad himself said, “I am the final prophet of God,” or that Allah commanded him to say so?
b) Muslims believe that Muhammad is the final messenger of God. Therefore, according to your own beliefs, where in the Quran does it state that Muhammad himself said, “I am the final messenger of God,” or that Allah commanded him to say so?
c) Muslims believe that Isa (Jesus) is the Messiah. Therefore, where in the Quran does it state that Isa himself said, “I am the Messiah,” or that Allah commanded him to say so?
Explanation: According to the teachings of the Bible—the Holy Scripture—Jesus is the “Word of God,” who is not separate from God but is an integral part of Him. Being one with God as the “Word,” Jesus is not a created being; He is God!
This “Word,” which emanated from God, is described as the Son of God. It is this Son who entered the world, took on human flesh, was born of a virgin, and became known as Jesus Christ.
For this reason, the Christian faith holds that “Jesus Christ is God manifested in the flesh.”
Question # 8
The Quranic Method for the Distribution of Inherited Property
(1) “Allah commands you regarding your children: the share of a son shall be equal to the share of two daughters. If there are only daughters—more than two—they shall receive two-thirds of the inherited property. If there is only one daughter, she shall receive one-half. If the deceased leaves behind children, each of his parents shall receive one-sixth of the estate. If the deceased leaves no children and his parents are his only heirs, then his mother shall receive one-third. If the deceased has siblings, then his mother shall receive only one-sixth. These shares are to be distributed only after the execution of any will left by the deceased and the settlement of his debts. You do not know which of your fathers or sons is more beneficial to you. These are the shares ordained by Allah. Indeed, Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise.” (Quran 4:11)
(2) “If your wives leave no children, you shall have half of what they leave behind. If they have children, then you shall have a fourth of what they leave behind—after the execution of any will they may have made or the payment of any debts they may have incurred. If you leave no children, your wives shall have a fourth of what you leave behind. If you have children, then your wives shall have only an eighth of what you leave behind—after the execution of any will you may have made or the payment of any debts you may have incurred. If a man or a woman dies as a ‘kalalah’ (meaning they have neither a surviving father nor a surviving son) and leaves behind a brother or a sister, then each of them shall receive a sixth. But if there are more than one, they shall share one-third of the estate equally—all this after the execution of any will the deceased may have made or the payment of any debts they may have incurred.” (Quran 4:12)
(3) “(O Prophet!) They ask you for a legal ruling (regarding ‘Kalalah’—a person who dies leaving no direct descendants or ascendants). Say to them: Allah Himself gives you a ruling regarding ‘Kalalah.’ If a person dies without leaving any children, and he has only one sister, she shall receive half of the property he leaves behind. If a woman dies without leaving any children, her brother shall be her heir. If there are two sisters (of the deceased), they shall receive two-thirds of the entire estate. If there are several brothers and sisters, then the share of one male shall be equal to the shares of two females. Allah explains this clearly to you, lest you go astray. Allah has full knowledge of all things.” (Quran 4:176)
Based on the instructions provided in the above verses, here are some principles to be followed in the distribution of a person’s estate:
a) Each parent receives one-sixth of the estate [4:11].
b) If there are children, a wife receives one-eighth of the estate; if there are no children, she receives one-fourth [4:12].
c) The share of one son is equal to the combined shares of two daughters [4:11].
d) The share of one daughter is half the share of one son. [4:11]
Example #1: In the event of the death of an individual named Abdullah, his surviving family members include a son, a daughter, a wife, and his mother. His estate—valued at Rs. 100,000—can be distributed among the surviving family members according to the aforementioned principles as follows:
To the mother: 1/6 = 0.1667 = Rs. 16,667
To the wife: 1/8 = 0.125 = Rs. 12,500
Total: Rs. 29,167 (1)
Remaining amount after distribution to the wife and mother: Rs. 100,000 – Rs. 29,167 = Rs. 70,833
To the son: 2/3 [of the amount remaining after the shares for the mother and wife have been deducted] = 0.6667 = Rs. 47,222
To the daughter: 1/3 [of the amount remaining after the shares for the mother and wife have been deducted] = 0.3333 = Rs. 23,611
Total: Rs. 70,833 (2)
Amount remaining after distribution to all: Rs. 100,000 – Rs. 29,167 (1) = Rs. 70,833; Rs. 70,833 – Rs. 70,833 (2) = 0
Distributing Abdullah’s estate in this manner, in accordance with the guidelines provided in the Quran, ensures an accurate and complete allocation. Example #2: Consider a man named Ahmed who has passed away, leaving behind three daughters, both his parents, and a wife. How should his property be distributed among his surviving family members, strictly following the aforementioned Quranic instructions?
Can any Muslim—or any preacher of the faith—accurately distribute the property based solely on these Quranic instructions?
If it is possible to distribute it accurately, please provide the details.
If, however, it is not possible to distribute the property correctly according to these Quranic instructions, does this not imply that the one who provided these instructions in the Quran lacked the ability to perform calculations?
How could someone who cannot perform calculations be God?
And how can teachings attributed to someone who lacks such mathematical ability be ascribed to the Creator?
Question #9
Who is the most influential person in history?
Dawah preachers compare their Prophet to the Lord Jesus Christ, claiming that he is greater than Jesus Christ. They make every possible effort to convince others of this. As part of this, they frequently cite modern authors who have expressed the view that “Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, holds the first place among the individuals in history who have most influenced the world.” There is some truth to this!
However, in this context, those who love the truth—seeking to uncover the actual reality—ask the proponents of this claim the following question:
You hold the view that, in history, Muhammad has influenced the world more profoundly than Jesus Christ. Very well!
But does this influence lie in loving one’s neighbors and enemies, or in killing them?
Question # 10
Rewards in Paradise
The Quran teaches that in Islam, faithful Muslim men, upon their death, are rewarded by God with beautiful young women as their wives. [Surah 52:17-29; 78:31-33]
Furthermore, according to the teachings of the Quran, what rewards does God grant to faithful Muslim women after they die? In this regard, how can it be claimed that the God revealed in the Quran does not show partiality between men and women?
If a Muslim woman—having been married to five different men at various times in this world (whether due to divorce or the death of her husbands)—lives as a faithful Muslim, receives the favor of Allah as described in the Quran, and passes away; and if those five Muslim men—who were her husbands at different times—also receive the favor of Allah and pass away, then, according to the teachings of the Quran, to whom will she be married in Jannah (Paradise)?
Question # 11
What Awaits Him and His Followers
Isa al-Masih (Jesus Christ)—the Savior, Prophet, and Lord sent by God (Allah)—knew what would befall both Himself and those who follow Him. [Luke 10:20] [John 8:14; 14:1-3].
However, the situation of the Prophet of Islam, Muhammad, is not the same.
“Say: ‘I am not a new kind of messenger, nor do I know what will be done with me or with you. I only follow what is revealed to me. I am no more than a clear warner.’” [Surah 46:9]
The Quran itself, which Muhammad brought, teaches that Muhammad did not know what would happen to him or his followers in the future.
Muhammad, who acknowledged this regarding his own future in the Quran, clarifies the matter further in the Hadith…
A narration by Umm al-Ala:
An Ansari woman, who had pledged allegiance to the Prophet regarding the allocation of housing for the migrants (Muhajirun), stated: “It was decided that Uthman bin Maz’un would stay with us (i.e., with the family of Umm al-Ala). Uthman fell ill, and I cared for him until he passed away. After he died, we covered him with a cloth. Then the Prophet came to us, and I said (addressing the deceased), ‘O Abu as-Sa’ib, may the mercy of Allah be upon you!’” I said, “I bear witness that Allah has honored you.” The Prophet asked, “How do you know that Allah has honored him?” I replied, “I do not know. May my father and mother be sacrificed for you, O Messenger of Allah! But if it is not ‘Uthman, then who else would be deserving of it?” He said, “By Allah, death has overtaken him. I hope for the best for him. By Allah, even though I am the Messenger of Allah, I do not know what Allah will do with me.” By Allah, I shall never again assert that anyone’s piety surpasses his.
This saddened me. Later, in a dream, I saw a stream flowing for ‘Uthman bin Maz’un. I went to the Messenger of Allah and told him about it. He remarked, “This represents his (good) deeds.” (Sahih al-Bukhari, Volume 5, Book 58, Number 266)
Given this, the state in which you find yourselves—believing that you are living according to his example within the religion of Islam—is surely one of complete uncertainty! If your own situation is like this, why do you invite others into the same state of uncertainty?
Question # 12
The Names of Those Who Wrote the Scripture
Some Dawah (Islamic outreach) proponents criticize the Bible—the complete divine scripture—by pointing out that the names of the authors for certain books within it are missing. They mockingly ask, “Who wrote these? How can you believe that something written by anonymous individuals is the Word of God?”
In the same vein, here are some questions for these Dawah proponents: The Quran, which you believe to be a divine scripture, consists of 114 surahs (chapters). Muhammad himself did not write down a single one of them. According to Islamic history, his companions (Sahaba)—who heard what he recited—wrote these verses down on whatever materials were available to them at the time (such as palm leaves, bones, white stones, animal skins, etc.).
In light of the above, regarding the 114 surahs of the Quran:
What is the name of the person who wrote the first surah?
What is the name of the person who wrote the second surah?
What is the name of the person who wrote the third surah?
Question # 13
The Just Punishment for Murder
The statement regarding the Quran, as found within the Quran itself, is as follows:
“Alif-Lam-Ra. This is a Scripture; its verses have been made precise, and then they have been explained in detail—from One who is Wise and All-Knowing.” (Quran – Surah 11:1)
“Should I seek a judge other than Allah, when He is the One who has sent down to you the Book, fully detailed? Those to whom We gave the Book know well that it has been sent down from your Lord in truth. Therefore, (O Prophet!) do not be among those who harbor doubts.” (Quran – Surah 6:114)
“We have brought to these people a Book which We have explained in detail, based on Our complete knowledge; it is a source of guidance and a mercy for those who believe.” (Quran – Surah 7:52)
Observe below how ‘clearly’ the Quran explains the judgment to be delivered in cases of homicide:
“O you who believe! The law of retribution (Qisas) has been prescribed for you in cases of homicide. For a free person…”
A free person for a free person, a slave for a slave, and a female for a female—[only these] are to be held accountable [in the context of retribution]. If the brother of the victim chooses to show mercy to the killer, he should rightfully demand ‘blood money’ (diya), and the killer should pay it in a proper manner. This is a concession and a mercy from your Lord. Whoever transgresses these limits thereafter shall face a painful punishment. (Quran – Surah 2:178)
Does this verse mandate that the killer must be executed as retribution for the victim? Why…?
Furthermore, the Quran states: “A free person for a free person, a slave for a slave, and a female for a female—[only these] are to be held accountable.” Does this imply that if a free person is killed, a free person must be executed in retaliation; if a slave is killed, a slave must be executed; and if a female is killed, a female must be executed…? If that were the case, then if a slave kills a free person, which free person should be executed in retaliation…? If a free person kills a slave, which slave should be executed in retaliation…? And if a man kills a woman, which woman should be executed in retaliation…? What is the clarity regarding the instructions in Surah 2:178? Where is it to be found…?
A person might cause the death of another unintentionally—for instance, if someone driving a car accidentally strikes and kills a pedestrian. Conversely, a person might kill another intentionally, driven by a grudge or malicious intent. These are not the same type of offense; therefore, both forms of killing should not be categorized together or subjected to the same judgment. This distinction—along with the corresponding penalties and resolutions—was clearly articulated in the Torah, which predates the Quran by two thousand years [Torah – Numbers 35:9–34].
Why are this distinction and clarity absent from the Quran’s provisions regarding the judgment to be applied in cases of homicide…?
Question # 14
Compensation for Homicide
In any society, one person may cause the death of another in two ways:
1) A person causes the death of another intentionally, driven by a grudge or a premeditated plan.
2) A person causes the death of another accidentally or by chance, without any prior plan or existing grudge.
The first instance constitutes murder; The second category is manslaughter. Both are crimes, yet they are not of the same nature.
For the second type of offense, the prescribed penalty is a lighter one—specifically, the payment of “blood money” (compensation for the loss of life).
However, for the first type of offense, legal systems generally mandate the most severe punishment available. In such cases, there is no provision for settling the matter through the payment of blood money. There are two reasons for this:
1) The value of one human life is equivalent to that of any other; a human life cannot be assigned a monetary value. If someone intentionally takes a human life, they must pay with their own life—the only equivalent value for the life taken. To impose a monetary penalty for murder is to trivialize the inherent value of a human life.
2) To whom is this “blood money” paid? To the victim’s close blood relatives. Those who investigate property disputes are well aware that a significant proportion of contract killings are, in fact, orchestrated by the victim’s own close relatives. Therefore, in cases of murder, not only does the payment of blood money fail to deliver justice to the victim, but it also creates a high risk that such a provision will be exploited by those very relatives. For the reasons mentioned above, laws across the world—as well as the Torah given through Moses—generally do not provide for “blood money” (compensation for homicide) in cases involving murder.
However, given that the Quran and Islamic law introduce the concept of “blood money” in cases of murder, what is the wisdom behind allowing for a practice that could potentially result in an injustice toward the victims?
Question # 15
The Science of Honeybees
Regarding the sign God gave to honeybees, the Quran states:
“And your Lord inspired the bee, saying: ‘Build your homes (hives) in the mountains, in the trees, and in the structures that people erect. Then, eat from all kinds of fruits and follow the paths your Lord has made easy [for you to traverse].’ From their bellies emerges a drink of varying colors, in which there is healing for mankind. Indeed, in this, there is a (great) sign for those who reflect.” (Quran – Surah 16:68-69)
Generally, honeybees are attracted to sweet substances—for example, cakes, fruits, soft drinks, and the like. However, bees primarily roam among trees and shrubs to collect nectar from flowers, storing it within a specialized compartment in their bodies. This collected nectar undergoes a process inside the bee’s body and is transformed into honey. How can a text that fails to recognize this remarkable, fundamental truth of creation—implying instead that honey is produced from fruits by suggesting one should “eat all kinds of fruits”—be considered a truly divine scripture? And how can such a message be attributed to the Creator?
Question # 16
The Sun and the Moon Subservient to Humans
“And He has subjected the sun and the moon to you, both constantly pursuing their courses. He has also subjected the night and the day to your service.” (Quran – Surah 14:33)
The sun and the moon are not subservient to humans. Humans have no influence whatsoever over them or their paths. Yet, the Quran makes such a declaration.
According to the teachings of the Quran, to whom, when, and in what manner did Allah—as described in the Quran—subject the sun and the moon? In what way is the statement made in the aforementioned Quranic verse a reality?
Question # 17
Knowledge of Previous Scriptures
The Quran frequently affirms the truth that the preceding scriptures—the Tawrat (Torah), the Zabur (Psalms), and the Injil (Gospel)—are divine revelations (Surah 5:43–47; 21:105).
The Quran also bears witness that during the time of the Prophet of Islam, Muhammad—that is, in the seventh century AD in the Arabian region—these earlier scriptures were in the possession of Jews and Christians, who were actively reading them (Surah 2:113; 7:157; 10:94).
Ancient manuscripts of these earlier scriptures, dating back to the fifth and sixth centuries—long before the time of Muhammad—are still available today. The Bible, as used by Christians today in their respective languages, has been translated from these ancient manuscripts that existed well before the advent of Islam and the time of its founder, Muhammad.
Furthermore, the Quran emphatically asserts that no one can alter the words of God (Surah 6:34, 115; 10:64; 15:9). Nowhere in the Quran is it stated—not even once—that one should neither believe in nor read the earlier scriptures (the Bible), on the grounds that Jews and Christians have altered them.
Yet, contemporary preachers propagate the false claim that the earlier scriptures—the Bible—have been corrupted. This is a notion never mentioned by Allah, never taught by the Prophet Muhammad, and never declared in the Quran. By leveling such false accusations against the scriptures—claiming either that the Bible held by Christians is not the original scripture, or that it is a collection of earlier scriptures which Christians have subsequently altered—these individuals are not only treading a path toward their own destruction but are also leading innocent Muslims astray.
In light of these facts, why do you persist in the delusion that you possess greater knowledge regarding the earlier scriptures than the Quran, the Prophet Muhammad, or even Allah Himself?
Question # 18
The Jews Did Not Kill Jesus
The Bible, the complete Holy Scripture, clearly declares that Jesus the Messiah [Jesus Christ] died, conquered death, and rose again (Luke 24:1–49; John 20:1–31; Revelation 1:18, 2:8).
The Quran does not contradict this truth anywhere. In fact, the Quran supports this biblical truth by stating the following:
“And [for] their saying, ‘Indeed, we have killed the Messiah, Jesus, the son of Mary, the messenger of Allah’—but they [the Jews] did not kill him, nor did they crucify him.” (Surah 4:157)
It should be noted that this Quranic passage refutes the claim made by the Jews—who boasted that they had killed Jesus. It does not state that no one killed or crucified Jesus, nor does it claim that Jesus never died or was never placed on a cross. What the Quran says is: “They [the Jews] did not kill him.”
While Christians acknowledge that what the Quran states in this context is true, Muslims often incorporate their own interpretations, leading to a teaching that differs from the actual statement found in the Quran. According to the Bible, it was not the Jews who killed Jesus (Isa al-Masih) or crucified him; it was the Romans. The Jews of that time neither had the right to execute a person nor the authority to carry out a crucifixion; therefore, they could not have done so. Instead, it was the soldiers of the Roman government—which ruled over the Jews at that time—who crucified him, and it was on the cross that he breathed his last.
It is noteworthy that while the Quran condemns the arrogant claims made by the Jews, it does not refute the fact that the Romans crucified Jesus, nor does it deny his death. In reality, although the Quran—and Muhammad himself—challenged many of the beliefs and practices held by Christians and Jews at the time, there is not a single word in the Quran that contradicts the account that the Romans crucified and killed Jesus (Isa al-Masih).
Nevertheless, certain Dawah (proselytizing) advocates, driven by a malicious intent to discredit the Bible—which is the complete Word of God—spread the false claim that Jesus (Isa al-Masih) was never crucified and never died. Why, then, do you propagate such falsehoods—claims that run counter not only to the Bible but also to the Quran itself?
Question # 19
Prayer to Allah
According to the teachings of Dawah advocates, the entire Quran consists of the words of Allah. If you believe this to be true, consider that the first Surah of the Quran, Al-Fatiha, contains 7 verses (ayat). These verses are, in fact, a prayer.
Whose prayer is this? And to whom—or for whom—was this prayer directed?
Question # 20
Everything is by Allah’s Will
According to the teachings of Dawah (Islamic outreach) preachers, it is Allah who determines everything that happens in this world. All good and evil are determined by Allah [as per the Quran (Surah 7:178-179; 10:99-100; 76:29-30; 81:28-29) and the Hadith (Sahih al-Bukhari 4:54:430; 2:23:444; 6:60:473; 9:93:641; and Sahih Muslim 33:6436; 33:6406)]. At the same time, it is also taught that Allah is infinitely merciful and perfectly just.
If an individual ends up in Hell, it implies that the person committed evil deeds deserving of punishment in Hell.
If that person committed evil deeds warranting Hell, it is because it was Allah’s decree.
If Allah had preordained the evil deeds committed by that individual, then there is no question of that person being able to avoid them.
Therefore, how can a God who predetermines that a person should go to Hell—and that the person should commit the very evil deeds that lead them to Hell—be the true God?
And if such a God exists, how can He be considered infinitely merciful and perfectly just?
Question # 21
Adoption
Taking in orphans, raising them, treating them as one’s own children, and granting them a status equal to that of one’s biological children has been recognized across all eras and cultures as a noble human virtue. No prophet, in any era, ever declared that adoption is wrong or contrary to the will of God.
In the Torah—delivered through Moses, who himself grew up as an adopted son—and in the scriptures revealed through subsequent prophets, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob never opposed the practice of adoption. On the contrary, the prophetic scriptures portray both those who are adopted and those who adopt as engaging in a noble and virtuous act.
However, is it reasonable for the Quran to depict adoption—a practice recognized in society as a highly virtuous deed—as having been abolished by God [Surah 33:4-5]?
In reality, according to the Quran, when and why was adoption abolished?
What is the connection between the abolition of adoption and Muhammad’s marriage to Zaynab [Surah 33:36-40]?
What is the rationale behind the claim made by some preachers—that while one may raise children, one must not formally adopt them?
[Zayd was the adopted son of Muhammad. Zayd’s wife was named Zaynab. Some time after their marriage—less than two years later—Zayd divorced his wife, Zaynab. Subsequently, Muhammad married Zaynab…] [Remarriage]
Question # 22
Remarriage after divorce
In the Tawrat (Torah)—the Book of God given through the Prophet Moses—as well as in the writings of the Prophets (Deuteronomy 24:1–4; Jeremiah 3:1–2), God has provided very clear instructions regarding remarriage following a divorce. Specifically, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob has declared it an abomination for a man to remarry his former wife if, after their divorce, she married another man and was subsequently divorced or sent away by that second husband.
Neither the Zabur (Psalms) nor the Injil (Gospel) contradicts the aforementioned divine revelation. Yet, does the Quran—which claims to contain revelations from Allah—not issue a command [Surah 2:229-230] that is entirely contrary to that earlier revelation? Is this not, in fact, in opposition to the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob?
What is the wisdom behind including such a command in the Quran?
Question # 23
Forgiveness of Sins by Allah
(1) According to the following Quranic verse, Allah forgives all sins:
“Say: ‘O My servants who have transgressed against themselves [by sinning]! Do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins. Truly, He is the Forgiving, the Most Merciful.’” (Quran 39:53)
(2) According to the following Quranic verse, however, Allah does not forgive the sin of shirk (associating partners with Him):
“Indeed, Allah does not forgive the act of associating partners with Him; but He forgives anything less than that for whomever He wills. And whoever associates partners with Allah has indeed committed a grave sin!” (Quran – 4:48)
(3) According to the following Quranic teaching, Allah forgives sins committed out of ignorance, provided that the individual repents immediately after realizing their mistake:
“Allah accepts the repentance of only those who commit an evil deed out of ignorance and then repent soon thereafter. Allah accepts the repentance of such people. Allah is All-Knowing, All-Wise.” (Quran – 4:17)
(4) According to the following Quranic verse, if there are any contradictions within the Quran, it proves that the Quran is not from Allah:
“Do they not, then, reflect upon the Quran? Had it been from anyone other than Allah, they would surely have found many contradictions in it!” (Quran – 4:82)
Questions:
A. (1) & (2) appear to be contradictory. If you believe they are not, please explain why.
B. (1) & (3) also appear to be contradictory. If you believe they are not, please explain why.
C. (2) & (3) appear to be contradictory. If you believe they are not, please explain why.
D. Based on the statements (1), (2), and (3) from the Quran mentioned above, is there any possibility of forgiveness for the sins you have committed in your life so far? If not, consider what your situation might be after death.
Question # 24
Prophets Who Are to Be Killed
The following two verses from the Quran state the following:
Some rejected Muhammad as a Prophet, boasting, “Allah is poor, and we are rich.”
Allah heard what they said to Muhammad in a spirit of defiance, and He is recording these words in a book.
Allah is also recording the fact that they unjustly killed the Prophets.
They are destined to taste a scorching fire.
“Allah has heard the words of those who said, ‘Allah is poor, and we are rich.’ We shall record what they have said, as well as their unjust killing of the Prophets. [We shall say to them,] ‘Taste the punishment of the scorching fire.'” “Give it a taste.” (Quran – 3:181)
Allah is recording the defiant attitude and the words of the people who lived during the time of Muhammad. Furthermore, Allah is also recording their unjust killing of the prophets. Who were the prophets killed by those individuals who lived during the time of Muhammad?
Question # 25
Taking an Oath
The act of swearing an oath—invoking someone or something as a witness—can be found in the Quran, as well as in the earlier scriptures—the Torah (Tawrat), the Psalms (Zabur), and the Gospel (Injil)—which collectively form the Bible.
Even today, in courts of law or when providing testimony before society, individuals may swear an oath—invoking religious scriptures or their own parents—to affirm that they are speaking only the truth and to lend credibility to their statements.
When taking an oath to attest to the truth, one chooses someone or something considered greater or more valuable than oneself; one would never choose something of lesser status or value. For instance, one would not swear an oath by an ant, an animal, a tree, or a stone.
In the earlier scriptures [the Bible], God, while making a promise to Abraham (Ibrahim), swore by Himself—stating that there was no one greater than Him by whom He could swear [Torah: Genesis] [22:16; Isaiah 45:23; The Gospel: Hebrews 6:13-14, 16]. It is important to note in this context that, in the earlier scriptures, God never once swore by any person or created being inferior to Himself.
However, in the Quran, we frequently see Allah swearing by created things—by the winds and the clouds (Surah 51:1-2), by the mountains (52:1), by the moon (74:32), by the city (90:1), and by the fig and the olive (95:1). What is the reason for this? What is the wisdom behind it? Does this distinction not serve as clear evidence that the God described in the earlier scriptures—the Torah (Tawrat), the Psalms (Zabur), and the Gospel (Injil)—is different from the God presented in the Quran?
Question # 26
Muhammad in the Earlier Scriptures
In an attempt to secure a place for Muhammad—the prophet of Islam—within the lineage of prophets, and to establish the authenticity of the scripture he brought, Islamic apologists continue to make futile efforts by interpreting the Bible through distorted explanations that reflect their own conjectures. This is to be expected!
Jesus—whom Christians believe to be the Prophet, the Messiah (Masih), the Lord, and the Savior— Christ [Isa Masih] — regarding Himself, in the Torah, the Psalms, and the books of the prophets He cited written accounts and proclaimed, with supporting evidence, that they were fulfilled in his own life.
If the Prophet of Islam belongs to the lineage of the biblical prophets, he ought to have been familiar with the scriptures written by those prophets. Furthermore, those who provided him with divine inspiration (wahy) should also have been aware of these scriptures.
It is possible that Muhammad could not have learned the details contained in earlier scriptures through the wahy (revelation) he received. However, the Quran and the Hadith frequently indicate that Jews and Christians lived in the cities of Mecca and Medina during that era, and that they read the Tawrat (Torah), Zabur (Psalms), and Injil (Gospel)—scriptures they possessed. Consequently, Muhammad should have been able to point to the words of the prophets—found within those very scriptures—that foretold his own arrival.
While Muhammad, the Prophet of Islam, was able to affirm—through divine inspiration (wahy)—that the earlier scriptures were indeed from God, he never once cited specific passages from them to demonstrate that they were fulfilled in his life, nor did he provide scriptural evidence to show that the prophets had foretold his coming. It is also noteworthy that the Quran offers no evidence-based explanation regarding this matter. Why was Muhammad himself unable to cite passages from the Torah, the Psalms (Zabur), and the Gospel (Injeel) and claim that they were being fulfilled in his own life?
Question # 27
Priests and Priestly Duties
God [YHWH/Jehovah], who revealed Himself in the Torah, the Psalms, and the books of the Prophets, provided His people not only with prophets and kings but also—most importantly—with priests and priestly duties. [Torah: Exodus, chapters 29 & 40; Numbers, chapter 18]
Jesus Christ [Isa al-Masih]—who came as a continuation of the prophetic lineage—along with His disciples/apostles, explained the role of priests and their priestly duties, detailing their fulfillment in the Gospel [Injil]. [Gospel: Luke, chapters 17 & 19; Hebrews, chapter 7; 1 Peter, chapter 2]
If Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, was indeed sent by God [Jehovah] as part of the prophetic lineage, why is it that the Quran contains no information regarding priests, priestly duties, or their fulfillment?
Question # 28
God as Father
In the Jewish and Christian scriptures, the Creator declares that He will be a Father to His people, and that His people will be His sons. If, as proponents of the Islamic faith claim, Islam is a continuation of the tradition of Judaism and Christianity, then why is it that in the Quran—the scripture of Islam—there are no instances where Allah is referred to as a “Father,” or where human beings are described as “sons” of Allah?
Question # 29
The Setting of the Sun
In the Quran, Allah describes the journey of a figure named Dhul-Qarnayn. The account is as follows:
(O Prophet!) They ask you about Dhul-Qarnayn. Say to them, “I shall recite to you a portion of his story.” We granted him authority on earth and provided him with the means to achieve all things. He set out on a path, and eventually, he reached the place where the sun sets—and he saw it setting into a muddy spring. Near it, he found a people. We said, “O Dhul-Qarnayn! You may either punish them or adopt a better course of action regarding them.” (Quran – 18:83-86)
The following points in these Quranic verses appear to be problematic:
a) Does a specific “place where the sun sets” actually exist? Or should this be interpreted in a different way? b) Can the sun “set in a muddy spring”? Even if one were to argue that the observer might have mistakenly perceived the sunset as occurring within a muddy pool, one must consider: this was surely not the first time he had witnessed a sunset, was it? Furthermore, shouldn’t the author describing the event have been aware of the actual reality?
Anyone with a basic understanding of the world could easily explain that a sunset is not an event caused by the sun sinking into water.
If one were to ask scientists about sunsets, they would clarify that a sunset does not occur because the sun submerges into water.
When asked about the description of the sunset in the Quran, those who propagate the faith (dawah proponents) explain that it is merely a description from the perspective of Dhul-Qarnayn.
However, when Muhammad himself was asked about this very matter, he stated the following…
[Sunan Abu Dawud; Hadith number 3991]
Abu Dharr reported:
I was riding behind the Messenger of Allah on a donkey at the time of sunset. He asked me, “Do you know where it sets?” I replied, “Allah and His Messenger know best.” He said, “It sets in a warm spring.” So, among the four explanations mentioned above regarding the ‘setting of the sun’—as referred to in Surah 18:83–86 of the Quran—which one is the truth…???
Question # 30
The killing of someone else in place of ‘Isa [Jesus]
And [for] their saying, “Indeed, we have killed the Messenger of Allah, ‘Isa, the son of Maryam” — (they faced the consequences). In reality, they did not kill him, nor did they crucify him. The truth is that someone who resembled him was presented to them. Those who differed concerning ‘Isa were in doubt about the matter; they had no certain knowledge, following only conjecture. In fact, they did not kill him.
(Quran 4:157)
Even though the phrase “someone who resembled him was presented to them” does not exist in the original Arabic Quran, why do Muslim translators include it, thereby attributing falsehoods to the Quran they believe in…? Furthermore, based on the aforementioned fabricated accounts, Muslims are led to believe that Allah—in order to rescue Isa [Jesus] from those seeking to kill him—substituted another person in his place. This substitute was made to resemble Isa, and was subsequently killed, while the real Isa was taken up to heaven without the knowledge of those present. Is it appropriate to attribute such a deceptive act to Allah?
In the Bible, the Creator was able to take His prophet Elijah from this world to heaven by sending a chariot of fire in the sight of all. [2 Kings 2:1–14]
Why, then, was Allah—as described in the Quran—unable to take Isa [Jesus] to heaven in such a miraculous and visible manner?
Question # 31
The Creation of Pairs
The Quran, which Muslims believe to be a divine scripture, states the following:
“And We have created all things in pairs, so that you may take heed.” (Quran – Surah 51:49)
It is a well-known fact that, in the natural world, living beings are generally created in pairs—that is, as male and female. However, Surely, divine scriptures ought to possess knowledge that goes even beyond this.
Regarding the statement in the Quran mentioned above—that “all things” were created in pairs—the use of the word “all” presents a significant problem. The reason is that not everything that has been created exists in pairs!
Furthermore, when it comes to human beings, there are those who are born as eunuchs (or intersex/asexual individuals in a biological sense) and do not have pairs. Were the authors of this Quranic verse unaware of this fact?
If they were aware, what was the intent behind writing it that way?
Question # 32
The Mention of Eunuchs
Although the number of eunuchs among the human population is very small, they are nonetheless a part of God’s creation. There are three types of eunuchs:
Those who are made eunuchs by others.
Those who make themselves eunuchs for the sake of devotion.
Those who are formed as eunuchs while in their mother’s womb and are born that way.
In earlier divine scriptures—the Torah and the Gospel (the Bible)—eunuchs are mentioned, and God’s promises are extended to them.
However, in the Quran—which Muslims believe to be the final divine scripture—there is no mention of eunuchs at all. However, it is written in the Quran as follows:
“Indeed, in the stories of these (peoples) there is a lesson for those who possess wisdom. This Quran is by no means a fabrication. Rather, it confirms the scriptures that preceded it and provides a clear explanation of everything. It serves as a source of guidance and mercy for those who believe.” (Quran – 12:111)
Questions:
- According to Islam, who created those who are born as eunuchs (intersex or those lacking typical male/female reproductive characteristics)?
- Why did the authors of the Quran fail to mention or write about eunuchs?
- According to the teachings of the Quran, men in Paradise will be granted beautiful women as wives. In this context, what is the situation for eunuchs according to the Quran’s teachings?
- While the Quran claims that it “provides a clear explanation of everything,” it fails to say a single word about eunuchs. Does this not imply that the Quran has made a false statement?
Question # 33
Plurality within Divinity
Throughout history—from the first century to the present day—Christians, based on scriptural evidence from the New Testament, have understood the nature of God (Allah) as a Trinity. They believe that within the Godhead—that is, within the one God—there exist the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit.
– Setting aside the question of whether the Christian faith is true or not, why does the Quran make a statement—which is far from the truth—implying that Christians believe in God (Allah) as the Father, the Son, and Mary (the mother)? [Surah 5:72-75, 116]
– Why does the Quran fail to mention, even once, the actual fact that Christians believe in God (Allah) as the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit? Is it because the authors of the Quran were unaware of the true nature of the Christian faith, because they misunderstood it, or because they intended to cast aspersions upon it?
– If the Quran had indeed originated from an all-knowing Creator, it ought to have provided accurate information regarding the Christian faith; why, then, did it fail to do so?
Question # 34
The Role of God as “Father”
Great prophets in the lineage of prophets—such as Moses, David, and Jesus Christ—were able to recognize and address God (Allah) as “Father”—not in a physical or literal sense, but in a spiritual or religious sense. [Deuteronomy 32:6; Psalm 89:26; John 17:3]
If Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, also belongs to this same lineage of prophets, why was he unable to address God (Allah) as “Father”?
Question # 35
Status in the World to Come
Prophets and apostles were aware of what their status would be in the world to come:
– Moses [Deuteronomy 32:32-33]
– Job [Job 19:25-26]
– David [Psalm 17:15]
– Jesus Christ [Luke 10:20; John 8:14; 14:1-3]
– Paul [Philippians 1:21-23; 2 Timothy 4:8]
If Muhammad, the prophet of Islam, truly belongs to this same lineage, why was he unable to know what his own status would be in the world to come?
Question # 36
Prayer for the Right Path
In their daily prayers (Salah), Muslims frequently beseech Allah, saying, “Guide us to the right path.” This is a commendable prayer—one that every individual who cherishes the right path should offer until they attain it.
“Show us the right path (the path of righteousness).” (Quran – 1:6)
Against this backdrop…
When is the “right path” actually revealed to those who follow the Islamic faith [Muslims]…?
If there is a possibility for Muslims to be guided onto the right path, when does that occur…?
When will Muslims reach a stage where they can worship Allah, saying, “We are grateful to You for guiding us to the right path”…?
Question # 37
The Process of Destined Destruction
In the Quran, Allah declares the following:
“When We intend to destroy a town, We issue commands to those among them who live in affluence; yet, they engage in disobedience. Thus, the decree (of punishment) is justified against them, and We then utterly destroy that town.” (Surah 17:16)
Based on these words from the Quran, one can understand the following:
(1) Allah decides to destroy cities—even without any specific reason!
(2) Allah carries out His decision to destroy cities in three steps:
First step: He issues certain commands to the people of that city.
Second step: The people of that city transgress the commands given by Allah. The reason for this is that Allah has already preordained their destiny—ensuring that they would indeed transgress [Surah 9:51].
Third step: In accordance with His predetermined decree, once the inhabitants of a city have transgressed His commands and become guilty, Allah destroys them on account of their transgressions. In this manner, Allah fulfills what He wills.
What is truly astonishing is that the Quran itself, while describing the attributes of Allah, states:
“To Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth. He forgives whom He wills, and He punishes whom He wills. And Allah is the Forgiving, the Merciful.” (Surah 48:14)
When He intends to destroy a city, why must Allah—who possesses absolute dominion over the heavens and the earth—go through such an elaborate and arduous process, as described in Surah 17:16?
Cannot Allah, who holds the sovereign authority to punish whomever He wills, simply destroy a city with ease, the moment He so desires?
Does Allah truly require a grand, three-step plan to destroy a city?
Question # 38
Prophecies Regarding the Deaths of Prophets
Moses (Musa) is a great prophet in the Torah, just as Jesus (Isa) is a great prophet in the Gospel (Injeel). God [Allah], who conveyed His message to humanity through these two prophets, informed them in advance about how their deaths would occur in this world [Deuteronomy 32:49-50; Mark 10:32-34]. Such prophecies can only be provided by the Creator.
If the God [Allah] who revealed the Quran is indeed the same God [Allah] who sent Moses (Musa) and Jesus (Isa), then why did He fail to inform Muhammad in advance about his own death?
Moreover, the God [Allah] who revealed the Quran poses the following question regarding the death of Muhammad:
“Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) is only a messenger; messengers have passed away before him. If he were to die or be killed, would you turn back [from Islam]?” (Quran 3:144)
Based on this question, it appears that the God [Allah] of the Quran did not possess precise knowledge as to whether His prophet, Muhammad, would die a natural death (due to old age) or be killed (an untimely death—whether by illness, an accident, or at the hands of enemies). How can a God who lacks precise knowledge regarding the manner of His own prophet’s death be the true God?
Question # 39
The Path to the Forgiveness of Sins
Throughout the lineage of the prophets—in the Tawrat (Leviticus 17:11), the Zabur (Psalm 4:5), and the Injil (Hebrews 9:22)—God (Allah) repeatedly made it clear that a sacrificial offering or the shedding of blood is necessary for the forgiveness of sins.
Muslim preachers claim that God (Allah) sent Muhammad as part of this prophetic lineage and delivered the message of the Quran through him. If this were true, why is there no mention in the Quran—nor any instruction from Muhammad—regarding the necessity of a sacrificial offering or the shedding of blood for the forgiveness of sins?
In reality, does this discrepancy not serve as strong evidence that neither Muhammad nor the Quran he brought has any connection to the lineage of the prophets or the scriptures revealed through them?
Question # 40
A Reversal on the Day of Judgment
In the Quran, Allah declares that He will forgive whom He wills and punish whom He wills…
“To Allah belongs the dominion of the heavens and the earth. He forgives whom He wills, and He punishes whom He wills. And Allah is the Forgiving, the Merciful.” (Surah 48:14)
Based on this, would you say that God [Allah] has the authority—or the possibility—to decide that, on the Day of Judgment, Muslims should go to Hell and non-Muslims should go to Paradise…?
If He does, what would be the fate of you and your Prophet…?!
Question # 41
Committing a sin after receiving guidance
“How shall Allah guide a people who disbelieved after having believed, and after bearing witness that the Messenger is truthful, and after clear proofs had come to them? And Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people. The punishment for such people is that the curse of Allah, the angels, and all of mankind shall be upon them! They will abide therein (in Hell) forever; their punishment will not be lightened, nor will they be granted any respite.” (Quran – 3:86-88)
“(O Prophet!) The People of the Book ask you to bring down a scripture upon them from the sky. In fact, they asked Moses for something even more outrageous, saying: ‘Show us Allah openly!’ Consequently, a thunderbolt struck them due to their wrongdoing. Even after clear proofs had come to them, they took the calf (as an object of worship). Yet, We forgave them for that, and We gave Moses clear authority.” (Quran – 4:153)
Both of the above are statements from the Quran. So, if one commits a sin even after receiving clear guidance, will Allah forgive it or not?
Question # 42
Forgiveness for the sin of Shirk (associating partners with Allah)
“Indeed, Allah does not forgive the act of associating partners with Him (Shirk). But He forgives anything other than that for whomever He wills. And whoever associates partners with Allah has, in truth, committed a grave sin!” — Quran 4:48
“Say: ‘O My servants who have wronged themselves (by committing sins)! Do not despair of the mercy of Allah. Indeed, Allah forgives all sins. Truly, He—and He alone—is the Forgiving (the Oft-Forgiving).’”
“…He is the Bestower of immense mercy.” (Quran – 39:53)
“And thus, in order that he might be among those who possess firm faith, We showed Abraham the dominion of the heavens and the earth. When the night grew dark over him, he saw a star and said, ‘This is my Lord!’ But when it set, he said, ‘I do not love those that set.’ Then, seeing the moon rising, he said, ‘This is my Lord!’ But when it set, he said, ‘If my Lord does not guide me, I shall surely be among those who have gone astray!’” (Quran – 6:75-77)
“(O Prophet!) Do not be surprised that the People of the Book ask you to bring down a scripture upon them from the heavens. In fact, they asked Moses for something even more outrageous, saying, ‘Show us Allah openly!’ Consequently, a thunderbolt struck them for their wrongdoing. Even after clear signs had come to them, they took the calf (as an object of worship). Yet, We forgave them for that, and We granted Moses clear authority.” (Quran – 4:153)
Based on the above statements from the Quran, does Allah forgive the sin of shirk (associating partners with Him), or does He not?
Question # 43:
“Those who follow this Messenger, the unlettered Prophet—whose description they find written in the Torah and the Gospel that they possess—(will be blessed)…” Quran – 7:157
If what the author of the Quran states in the verse above is true, then why—as the author himself acknowledges within the same verse—was he unable to show the Jews and Christians of his time in Medina the evidence he claimed existed in the Torah and the Gospel, the scriptures they were reading?